Tag Archives: medical students

The Effectiveness of Using Medical Students for Training High School Students in Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation

DOI: 10.1515/amma-2016-0005

Introduction: Training for cardiopulmonary resuscitation is a very important topic for society, trainers and researchers. However it is not yet established who should be trained and by whom nor how the training programmes should be accomplished. We developed a study to evaluate an existing programme where medical students train high school students in cardiopulmonary resuscitation using instrumented mannequins to teach and collect performance data.
Method: The students of four randomly selected high school classes were trained by four randomly selected medical students and were evaluated by an independent evaluator. The level of knowledge provided and the level of technical skills acquired were analysed.
Results: One hour of lecturing was enough to increase the mean of correct answers from 39.52% to 78.48% when we tested knowledge. Testing for skills retention we found that that 92.75% of trained students taped the shoulder; 95.65% asked loudly “Are you all right?” at the right moment; 97.1% shouted for help at the right moment, the entire group remembered to check the breathing at the right moment, and 92.75% executed a correct head tilt chin lift manoeuvre; 86.9% remembered to call 112 at the right moment. Automatic recordings showed that mean flow fraction was 80.74%, mean no flow time was 18.9 seconds, mean frequency of chest compressions was 134.7/min and mean compression depth was 39.06 mm.
Conclusions: The results showed that high school students achieved a good level of knowledge and acceptable cardiopulmonary resuscitation skills when trained by medical students.

Full text: PDF

Medical Students’ Acceptance of Online Assessment Systems

DOI: 10.1515/amma-2015-0110

Objective: The increased use of computers in education lead to computerized assessments, especially web-based assessment systems The aim of this study is to evaluate students’ acceptance of being evaluated using an online web-based assessment system.
Methods: A transversal study was performed where a sample of students that used and were accustomed to an online assessment system were asked to fill in a short questionnaire and evaluate its use.
Results: The questionnaire items responses show students’ preference for online assessment, as opposed to other assessment forms, like oral examination or classical pen and paper examination. Also it is noticeable the increase in the student number that prefer the online assessment as we move up through one year of study to the next.
Conclusions: The study revealed a high level of acceptance for the online multiple choice questions test as an assessment method. Students’ opinion is that online tests are better suited for knowledge assessment and are more objective.

Full text: PDF

Attitudes and Preferred Information Sources in Medical Students and Family Doctors Regarding Organ Donation and Transplantation

Background: Organ transplantation is a modern treatment for many patients, however current organ shortage determines the need to identify strategies to eliminate barriers and increase organ donation rate. Aim of the study is to determine present and future health care professionals’ attitude and methods of further knowledge acquisition on the topic of organ donation and transplantation.
Material and method: We performed a cross-sectional survey in a study population consisting of preclinical medical undergraduates and of general practitioner doctors, the self administered questionnaires were anonymously statistically analyzed, the association between variables was considered significant for values p <0.05.
Results: One-hundred forty students and 48 doctors participated in our study, both groups showed positive attitude towards organ donation, 81.4% and 68.8% respectively were willing to donate own organs after death. Previous family discussions determined significant change of attitude among students but not within the group of doctors. Formal earlier education on the topic of transplantation was reported by 25% of the students but by none of the doctors. Preferred information channels are medical journal articles in both groups (37.9% vs. 35%), additionally medical students would prefer lectures and seminars while doctors would like to receive information during conferences and congresses. Internet is chosen (30–32%) over classical mass media.
Conclusions: although health care professionals have a natural inclination towards accepting donation and transplantation, providing information is essential in structuring their attitude in the way of promoting an environment that has a positive influence on organ donation rates.

Full text: PDF

Outside over Inside Analysis of Medical Students’ Education Efficacy in Cognitive Domain over a given Physiology Curricula

Aim: We tried to correlate, in cognitive domain, the second year medical students’ oral evaluation results to the efficacy of education they were provided, over our medical physiology curricula between 2004 and 2011.
Material and methods: We used the fact that during the mentioned period the curricula configuration for the two semesters of the second year was identical. We also used the fact that, for a given group of students and curricula, education and evaluation were performed by the same teacher. We compared three existing and unmodified configurations: 1. different groups of students, same curricula, different teachers, 2. same group of students, different curricula, same teacher and 3. same group of students, different curricula, different teachers. We also took an inside brief evaluation of students’ skills in cognitive domain at the beginning of the second year and tried to correlate it with final results.
Results: We couldn’t make any correlations because of logical contradictions of the configurations we compared. We couldn’t obtain, as an outside observer, concise information of what levels in cognitive domain students were evaluated on by different teachers. Merely we can say that education of the second year medical students over our physiology curricula cannot be efficient for a large amount of students who do not possess those compulsory cognitive skills that are required to study physiology.
Conclusions: The protocols used between 2004 and 2011 for evaluating medical students’ skills in cognitive domain over second year medical curricula cannot give accurate information for an outside evaluator.

Full text: PDF

Assessment of Medical Students’ Perception on the Healthcare System

Purpose: Major transformations going through the medical system have a significant impact on medical students, future physicians and their perception is a key factor in the ongoing evolution of the medical practice. We assessed medical students’ perceptions on healthcare system, patients care, the ethics of medicine, and the understanding of health policies.
Material and method: We studied data from 415 medical students who completed a survey questionnaire during a period of five months. Applied questionnaire was completed individually with single choice questions and privacy was respected. Students had the opportunity to make comments and sugestions to complex issues.
Results: In terms of professional orientation, an equal number of students opted for a medical and surgical specialty, while for medical research field there were only 10 responses. 91% of students believe that the medical system in Romania is not effective, while 47% considered the system is partially efficient. The perception on the healthcare system worsens as medical students approach their final years.
Conclusions: Students have shown pragmatism regarding the answers that targeted their professional options, the place where they want to practice, their choice of specialty and their perception of the healthcare system. The questionnaire identified major deficiencies in terms of financing of the health system, the ineffective administration of resources, poor management and low wages.

Full text: PDF